Table of Contents
- Non-Toxic Baby Crib Mattresses Buying Guide
- Review of the Top 5 Non-Toxic Crib Mattresses
When a newborn is taken home, safety will be at the forefront of their parents’ minds. Preparing the house for the new family member implies several tasks and getting the right non-toxic crib mattress should be a priority.
Any standard-sized crib will need a proper baby mattress for your baby to safely sleep on. Unfortunately, SUDC, which is the sudden death of a child that is 12 months old or older, is still a medical mystery that remains unexplained and can’t be fully prevented. The good news is, nonetheless, acquiring a baby crib mattress composed of open-cell foam, or any breathable composition significantly reduces the risk of suffocation in babies and toddlers up to 60-70%. Some small babies are stubborn and prefer to sleep on their tummies. Some of them even sleep with their faces buried in the mattress. Therefore, comfort and breathability are two main characteristics that any brand should offer in their children’s bedding products.
In this article, we will highlight trustworthy brands that are concerned about the safety of their baby bedding products, plus our 5 picks.
Non-Toxic Baby Crib Mattresses Buying Guide
First and foremost, we must define what a non-toxic baby crib mattress is. The NFPA (The National Fire Protection Association of America) recommends adding certain chemicals to highly flammable products such as mattresses as a flame retardant measure. Some brands have reported using hazardous materials such as fiberglass layers in the inner composition of their king, queen, twin, and full-sized mattresses. But, what about products for toddlers and newborns?
Here’s a quick checklist of what you should look for in a baby crib mattress:
Certifications: Whereas adult-sized mattresses can allow certain chemicals in their composition when it comes to baby mattresses, it’s a different story. Checking the safety certifications and awards that a brand or a specific baby mattress holds will give you guidance about the composition and materials it has been built with.
CertiPUR, Greenguard Gold, ASTM are just three of the many organizations that rate baby mattresses (and mattresses in general) as low in VOC emissions. They certify them as eco-friendly and, in many cases, as recyclable. Some renowned brands use cotton fibers as a fire retardant in their crib mattresses, whereas other companies proudly announce their mattresses are made of recycled bottles and are fiberglass-free.
Thickness, size, and impermeability: The average size for a standard crib mattress is 27.25 x 51 inches, and the thickness should not be higher than 6 inches, it is a good idea to measure your crib in advance, before purchasing a crib mattress; you can even use the rule of the “two fingers”. If you can fit more than two fingers between the crib and the bare mattress, the mattress won’t be adequate for the crib.
Also, looking for waterproof covers (some are zippable and removable) in your mattress is a good idea as leaking accidents happen, and your mattress should be dry and fresh for your baby’s comfort. You should also look for impermeable mattress covers that do not compromise the breathability of the product. It is important that your baby can breathe through the mattress, not only to avoid suffocation risk but to prevent other respiratory and allergy problems.
Price & Warranty: A usual complaint about non-toxic crib mattresses that are sold online have to do with them being pricey. Some parents think that spending more than $200 or $300 on a bedding product that their baby will outgrow fast is not worth it, even if the mattress may offer a sophisticated array of materials in its composition.
Some brands keep it ‘cheap’ but practical and safe. Look for certified foam mattresses that cost between $80- $150. Some of them are made of recycled materials and can offer you more than 30 days of warranty. Check for the store’s refund policies in advance, and compare prices between online stores, physical stores, and the manufacturer’s site.
Below we have our top 5 picks for non-toxic baby crib mattresses.
Review of the Top 5 Non-Toxic Crib Mattresses
Manufacturer, color, stage: The always eco-friendly Babyletto brand is the first one on this list, featuring their Pure Crib Mattress. This is a very comfortable, lightweight, 2-stage dual-sided baby mattress that includes a soft and breathable waterproof cover that protects the mattress against accidents, keeping moisture out. It is highly recommended by pediatricians for its non-toxic, hypoallergenic composition. It is ideal for your baby if they are a tummy sleeper. It comes in white color and a pack of 1.
Dimensions, Weight, and Thickness: The Babyletto Pure Core Crib baby mattress is a ‘resting cloud’ for your baby as it is 5.5 inches thick, measures 52 x 27.75 inches, and weighs 14 pounds. It is designed to fit any standard crib and it is soft but firm enough for your baby to breathe into it.
Type of fabric and fill materials: This baby mattress is made mainly of cotton with a comfortable memory foam inner layer. Its top cover is PVC-free. Instead, it is made of a natural viscose fabric that makes it impermeable, elastic, and removable for machine or hand washing. Also, this mattress has a wovenaire comfort polymer filling in its composition that has been proven to be more breathable than 100% organic mattresses.
Safety: Babyletto’s baby mattresses are Greenguard Gold certified, which means they have been tested low in chemical components and VOCs (Volatile Organic Compounds), making them safe for your baby and eco-friendly. Also, the 100% recyclable polyester core does not contain any chemical flame retardants such as fiberglass, PVC, synthetic latex, or artificial dyes. Instead, it uses modacrylic, which is a textile fiber (synthetic) that has been proven to be much safer as a fire stopper in baby mattresses.
Other features: This baby mattress is a dual-use product, which means its inner memory foam core allows it to be flippable and can be reused on both sides if necessary. It has a toddler side(softer) and an infant side(firmer). Also, its removable cover is elastic, easy to wash, and dries very quickly.
Manufacturer, color, stage: The Newton brand known in the market for their high-quality baby sleeping products are listed here with their classical Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler bed. This is a 2-stage breathable, comfortable mattress your baby can breathe through even if they are face or tummy sleepers. Its cover is completely washable, plus hypoallergenic. It can be chosen in a fun variety of colors: White, Pink, Moonlight Grey, and Sky Blue.
Dimensions, Weight, and Thickness: The Newton original Baby Crib Mattress is 5.5 inches thick. It measures 52 x 28 inches and weighs 11 pounds. Its size and thickness make it suitable to fit almost any standard-sized crib. Also, it is a dual-use mattress which means it is a flippable mattress that can be reused (one side for toddlers, one side for infants).
Type of fabric and fill materials: This deluxe Newton baby crib mattress is mainly composed of comfort foam (dual-layer) and wovenaire, a 90% air and 10% food-grade breathable polymer that is safe for your baby to breathe through. It includes a natural viscose, chemical-free cover that is easily removable and machine or hand washable. Check for deals on Amazon to purchase a second cover that can come in handy whilst the other one is in the wash.
Safety: The NFPA (The National Fire Protection Association) is an American program that is always concerned about the flammability of commercial products like mattresses. They recommend adding certain chemical components as a fire-stopper measure in memory foam mattresses. Newton’s baby mattresses are GreenGuard certified and composed of materials that aren’t highly flammable or toxic.
Other features: This mattress stands out thanks to its innovative Breathe-Thru Technology that significantly reduces the risk of suffocation and CO2 rebreathing. Although (SUDC) can’t be prevented, open fiber mattresses reduce the risk significantly, plus, this can be a suitable mattress for babies suffering from allergies.
Manufacturer, color, stage: Delta Children, an American-based company that has been manufacturing children’s bedding products for over 50 years, is third in this list featuring their Delta Children Twinkle Stars Dual-sided mattress. It is a lightweight stage 2 toddler/infant mattress that is durable, waterproof, and easy to clean. Its square corners help the mattress to fit tight into the crib or the toddler’s bed. It comes in light grey color and a pack of 1.
Dimensions, Weight, and Thickness: This is a super lightweight mattress. It weighs barely 9 pounds, measuring 52 x 27.5 inches. It is a firm mattress with a thickness of 6 inches. It comes with the flippable (toddler-softer side / infant-firmer side) option and fits standard cribs and little kid’s beds. Your baby can grow months in it.
Type of fabric and fill materials: This eco-friendly mattress is made of upcycled plastic bottles, with a firm polyester fiber core (foam). It gives firm support to your baby, plus a resistant, waterproof/impermeable, and stain-proof vinyl cover that is removable, elastic, and washable in case of accidents, preserving the freshness of your mattress for longer.
Safety: Delta Children are always concerned about eco-friendly materials and openly disclose that their baby products are free from harmful components/chemicals/substances and flame retardants. This baby mattress is Greenguard Gold and ASTM certified for safety and its foam is CertiPUR-US approved.
Other features: This mattress is an innovative recycled product that helps the environment and is free from chemicals. By purchasing this specific model, you save 300 plastic bottles from the landfill.
Manufacturer, color, stage: Since 1955, Colgate Mattress has been a top seller in the children’s bedding products market by releasing American-made crib mattresses of high quality. They feature in this list with their Eco Classica III, a stage 2 (baby and toddler) dual mattress that is comfortable, and waterproof. This is a high-quality organic mattress for your baby’s comfort. Its firm construction prevents suffocation risk in newborns. It comes in white color and a pack of 1.
Dimensions, Weight, and Thickness: The Colgate Eco Classica III measures 52 x 27.75 inches with a thickness of 6 inches. It is a firm, lightweight mattress that fits in almost any standard-sized crib. Let’s remember that the size of standard baby cribs is regulated by the Federal US Government, via the CPSIA (Consumer Product Safety Improvement). The recommended/minimum safe size must be 27.25 inches x 51 inches with a thickness that does not exceed 6 inches.
Type of fabric and fill materials: This baby mattress is eco-friendly and organic. It comes with a very soft, snuggly cotton cover, that has a waterproof backing for the mattress to remain dry whilst your baby’s skin rests on top of the organic cotton fabric. The mattress includes a layer of plant oils infused CertiPUR certified Eco Foam. The inverted seams provide extra durability to your baby’s mattress through their infant and toddler years.
Safety: Colgate exceeds all the US government safety standards in children’s bedding products. This mattress includes a natural cotton flame retardant in its composition and does not contain any harmful, toxic chemicals such as fiberglass that can be hazardous for your baby. This is a product of ‘many medals’ as it holds a good number of safety certifications and is approved by the Consumer Product Safety Commission of the US.
Other features: Not only is this a dual-use organic breathable baby mattress, Colgate proudly announces this product is the Eco Excellence Award winner (2021) for its eco-friendly composition.
Manufacturer, color, stage: The renowned Graco brand that manufactures mattresses for all your family needs, is the last one in this list, featuring their Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress. It is a dual-use super practical baby mattress with the Graco seal of quality, that comes with a washable water-resistant cover. Its inner foam composition gives comfort to your baby, but also, the firmness they need to grow older. It comes in white color in a pack of 1. Just like any other Graco product, this mattress comes rolled up, vacuum-sealed in its box. Wait for at least 72 hours for the mattress to fully expand after unpacking it.
Dimensions, Weight, and Thickness: The Graco premium baby mattress measures 51.63 x 27.25 inches and weighs 14 pounds. It is designed to fit any standard crib and is soft but firm enough for your baby to breathe into it. It is 5 inches thick.
Type of fabric and fill materials: This mattress contains JPMA Certified (Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association) breathable foam layers that give the right firmness to the mattress for infants growing in it. It also comes with a machine washable, water-resistant, zippable, removable cover made of breathable fabrics that should be naturally aired. Do not put this cover in the dryer machine.
Safety: This mattress is Greenguard Gold certified, CertiPUR-US certified, tested low in VOC’sand it doesn’t contain heavy metals or toxic substances such as mercury, lead, and formaldehyde. Its composition is free from ozone depleters. This is an environmentally safe product for your baby.
Other features: This baby mattress is a dual-use product that has a side for small babies and a side for toddlers, plus it holds a good number of awards and certifications. It has won the National Parenting Products Award and it is the 2021 Winner of the Women’s Choice Award and the PTPA (Parent Tested, Parent Approved) Award, which is an independent organization that gives quality labels to a wide array of household products aimed at children.
Dual-use mattresses are extremely helpful as they are prepared for your baby to grow whilst sleeping on them. Dual mattresses have a soft side for babies and a firmer side for toddlers, you flip the mattress when your baby is old enough to use the reverse side and if properly taken care of. This is a two-in-one product that will make you save money in the long run.
In the product list mentioned above, we reviewed some of the brands that manufacture mattresses that are safe for babies and toddlers, certified for low VOCs, and manufactured without heavy metals and toxic chemicals that may work as fire retardants. Make sure you check the Colgate, Graco, Newton, Babyletto, and Delta Children Amazon stores for similar baby products you may be interested in buying.
They may be. Polyester foam padding has been tested to expel significant amounts of VOCs (off-gassing). Therefore, they are considered harmful for small children’s health, and for anyone sleeping on top of such padding layers as they may cause respiratory issues, skin diseases, and allergies. Polyester should be merged/mixed with more benign materials usually of organic nature to be freely used as foam padding that can be considered safe.
No. Polyurethane foam is potentially harmful and suspected to be carcinogenic if manufactured incorrectly or not properly handled by the factory that produces it.
Although some brands claim that the final product is inert and doesn’t cause harm to users, the sole manufacture of the material has been reported as hazardous for the workers involved in the process.
Some chemicals used as flame retardants have been tested as toxic in products like mattresses and car seats. It is important to buy mattresses that have been certified as low in chemical emissions and that have CertiPUR certified foam layers in them especially if the bedding product is going to be used by your children.
Definitely, it is worth it paying a bit more for a baby crib mattress that has been tested as non-toxic and safe for your kid to breathe through it. Organic mattresses or crib mattresses that contain organic, breathable materials in them are a great alternative to go back to the basics and provide your baby with the more natural, hypoallergenic sleeping surface possible, helping their healthy development whilst offering them many nights of cozy, lovable comfort.